Home World US Texas shock on the cards? Paxton and Talarico locked in dead heat as Democrats eye first statewide win in 30 years

Texas shock on the cards? Paxton and Talarico locked in dead heat as Democrats eye first statewide win in 30 years

2025 Texas State Capitol 03

Texas has not elected a Democrat to statewide office in more than 30 years. With four days to go, the race for the Senate seat John Cornyn lost in the Republican primary is close enough that neither party is willing to call it. Polls published this week put Republican Ken Paxton and Democrat James Talarico within a couple of points of each other, and the latest survey has the Republican fractionally in front.

Early voting closed on Friday evening with turnout well ahead of the last midterm, leaving both camps to fight over the voters who have yet to cast a ballot on Tuesday.

A race on a knife-edge

The most recent poll, from Quantus Insights, surveyed 1,221 likely voters between 26 and 28 October and put Mr Paxton on 48.7 per cent to Mr Talarico’s 47.6 per cent, a gap well inside its 3.2-point margin of error, FOX 7 Austin reported. More than half of those polled said they had already voted.

A Texas Southern University survey of 2,000 likely voters, carried out a few days earlier, had the reverse result: Mr Talarico on 49 per cent, Mr Paxton on 47 per cent and Libertarian Ted Brown on 3 per cent, which USA Today described as a statistical tie. A Fox News poll released on 21 October had the two men level on 49 per cent each, after Mr Talarico led by two points in September.

Across the dozen or so polls USA Today listed since early October, the Democrat has led or tied in every one, usually within the margin of error. His leads ranged from nothing to six points.

Who is backing whom

The Fox News poll illustrates the coalitions. Mr Talarico, a state legislator and former teacher, led among Hispanic voters by 64 per cent to 34, a striking figure in a state where that group narrowly backed Donald Trump in 2024. He also had big leads among Black voters, under-30s and college-educated women. Mr Paxton, the state’s attorney general, dominated among white evangelicals, white men without degrees and rural voters.

READ MORE

The Republican has a likeability problem. Fox found 58 per cent of likely voters viewed Mr Paxton unfavourably, against 48 per cent for his opponent. But voters also had doubts about Mr Talarico: 53 per cent worried his positions were too liberal, while 50 per cent worried Mr Paxton was too close to Mr Trump. Texans as a whole still said they would prefer Republicans to control the Senate, by 51 per cent to 47.

Mr Paxton won the Republican nomination by beating Mr Cornyn in a May runoff with 63 per cent of the vote after Mr Trump endorsed him, Newsweek reported. Mr Talarico beat congresswoman Jasmine Crockett for the Democratic nomination in March. The two have not debated, with Mr Paxton saying he would only consider it under the right conditions.

Money and turnout

Mr Talarico has a huge cash advantage. Federal Election Commission filings cited by Newsweek show he raised $146.3 million up to 14 October, compared with $22.3 million for Mr Paxton. Republican-aligned outside groups have narrowed the gap on the airwaves, committing more than $214 million to ads supporting Mr Paxton or attacking his opponent, according to AdImpact.

More than 6.3 million Texans had voted early by Friday, Newsweek reported, and by midweek turnout was about 50 per cent higher than at the same point in 2022. Analysis by Republican data consultant Derek Ryan, reported by the Texas Tribune, found that in the first week voters with a history of voting in Democratic primaries slightly outnumbered those with a Republican primary record, something he described as new territory. Texas does not register voters by party, so these are estimates.

Republicans believe they have reserves to call on. NBC DFW, citing Republican researchers, said more than a million reliable Republican voters had not voted as of Thursday, and around 40 per cent of Republicans told the Texas Politics Project they planned to vote on election day itself. Rice University political scientist Mark Jones told Newsweek the result could hinge on how many Republicans defect.

What happens next

Polls are open from 7am to 7pm local time on Tuesday 3 November, which means results will come in during the early hours of Wednesday in Ireland. Mr Trump campaigned for Mr Paxton in Corpus Christi and Lubbock this week. A Talarico win would make it far easier for Democrats to gain the four seats they need to control the Senate. A Paxton win would close off one of their most ambitious routes to a majority.

Sources

Featured image: 2025 Texas State Capitol 03 by Farragutful, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.