Home Culture Film Halloween box office shock: Elizabeth Holmes documentary tipped to beat DC’s Clayface to No 1

Halloween box office shock: Elizabeth Holmes documentary tipped to beat DC’s Clayface to No 1

Movie theater interior

It is not often a documentary goes toe to toe with a superhero film for the top of the box office. But this Halloween weekend, that is exactly the race forecasters are predicting in North America, where Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s You Can See Everything is squaring up to DC’s Clayface for No 1.

The documentary that keeps growing

You Can See Everything, released by A24, follows Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes in the weeks before she began her prison sentence. According to Nerdist, Holmes invited a sceptical film crew to document her 34 days before she was due to report to prison, and the project turned into a three-year undertaking; Fielder, best known for Nathan for You and The Rehearsal, moved in with Holmes and her family to film it.

Video: You Can See Everything | Official Trailer HD (A24 / YouTube)

Rather than fading after release, the film has grown. Rotten Tomatoes reported that it took $19.5 million in its second weekend, 23 to 25 October, up 25 per cent on its opening, as it expanded from 855 to 2,655 cinemas. That pushed its ten-day total to $45.1 million. By that measure, Rotten Tomatoes said, it was already among the highest-grossing documentaries ever released in US cinemas, and third behind Fahrenheit 9/11 and March of the Penguins if music films and long-running IMAX releases are excluded.

JoBlo reported that the film has now passed $50 million in North America and is expanding to more than 3,000 screens this weekend.

Clayface hits back

Standing in its way is Clayface, the DC horror-tinged comic-book film that opened at No 1 last weekend with $24 million, according to Rotten Tomatoes, on a reported budget of $44 million. JoBlo noted that the film earned a strong A-minus CinemaScore from audiences, though it still expects a drop of more than 50 per cent in its second weekend.

READ MORE

The forecasts are split. JoBlo predicts You Can See Everything will top the chart with about $15 million, ahead of Clayface on roughly $12 million. Box office blogger Todd M Thatcher has it the other way round, with Clayface on $13.5 million and the documentary on $12.9 million. Either way, the gap is tight enough that the final ranking may not be clear until Sunday’s estimates.

Why Halloween is so quiet

With Halloween falling on Saturday, forecasters expect parties, trick-or-treating and other events to keep many would-be cinema-goers away. JoBlo described the outlook as a very slow weekend, and few studios have chosen to open major new films into it.

The remaining top-five places are expected to go to holdovers. Laika’s stop-motion animation Wildwood, directed by Travis Knight, is forecast to take about $8 million after an $11.6 million opening. Video game adaptation Street Fighter, which fell 72 per cent in its second weekend to $8.6 million, is predicted to earn $4-5 million, and horror sleeper Wicker, which gave distributor Black Bear its best opening yet, is expected to take $3-4 million.

New arrivals include the Liam Neeson thriller The Mongoose, the festive comedy Christmas with the Kringles and the horror comedy Briarcliff, but none is forecast to break into the top five. Thatcher estimated Briarcliff at around $2 million to $2.5 million from about 1,800 screens.

What it means for Irish cinema-goers

Release dates in Ireland and the UK do not always match the US. Readers hoping to catch You Can See Everything, Clayface or Wildwood on the big screen should check local cinema listings, as the documentary’s wider international rollout may differ from its American expansion.

What happens next

Studio estimates for the weekend are due on Sunday 1 November, with final figures on Monday. If You Can See Everything does take top spot, it will be a rare case of a documentary leading the US weekend chart, and a significant win for A24. The next big test for cinemas comes as November’s awards contenders and holiday blockbusters begin to arrive.

Sources

Featured image: photo by Augusto Oazi on Unsplash.