Home World Pakistan jails famous rights lawyer couple for 10 years under terror laws – over road barriers

Pakistan jails famous rights lawyer couple for 10 years under terror laws – over road barriers

Supreme Court of Pakistan, Islamabad by Usman Ghani

Two of Pakistan’s best-known human rights lawyers, Imaan Zainab Mazari-Hazir and her husband Hadi Ali Chattha, have each been sentenced to 10 years in prison by an anti-terrorism court, in a case that began with a row over road barriers in Islamabad two years ago. Rights groups have reacted with alarm, and the couple’s lawyers say they will appeal.

The verdict

Judge Tahir Abbas Sipra delivered the verdict on Thursday 29 October at Adiala jail in Rawalpindi, where the trial was held and where the couple have been detained. According to Dawn, the court convicted them under Section 7(h) of Pakistan’s Anti-Terrorism Act, finding they had seriously coerced or intimidated public servants, and imposed a 10-year term and a fine of Rs100,000 each, roughly €310.

They were also convicted of obstructing a public servant and of using assault or criminal force to deter officials, receiving shorter terms that will run at the same time as the 10-year sentence. The judge acquitted them of criminal conspiracy, criminal intimidation, armed rioting and unlawful assembly, saying, according to Arab News, that the prosecution had not proved those charges beyond reasonable doubt.

A row over road barriers

The case dates back to October 2024, when roads in Islamabad were closed as part of security arrangements for a visiting international cricket team. Prosecutors said the couple removed barriers, let motorcyclists through and obstructed and assaulted police officers. Arab News reported that the court relied on police testimony and video footage, which a forensic examination found had not been edited. In his ruling, the judge linked the importance of the security arrangements to the 2009 attack on Sri Lanka’s cricket team in Lahore, and said the pair’s aim had been to undermine security by putting pressure on officials.

The couple deny the charges. In statements seen by Reuters and reported by Dawn, they described themselves as prisoners of conscience and said they had been targeted because of their legal work. Their defence argued the evidence was contradictory and that Ms Mazari-Hazir had herself been injured by police.

READ MORE

Fair trial concerns

Much of the criticism focuses on how the case was run. Dawn reported that the court appointed a state defence counsel, and the couple complained that the trial was held inside a jail and that they were kept in a cage during hearings. Ms Mazari-Hazir’s mother, Shireen Mazari, a former human rights minister in Imran Khan’s government, told Reuters they were not allowed to be defended by a lawyer of their choice and were denied key documents.

Human Rights Watch said those claims raise serious due process concerns and called for the convictions to be quashed. Its senior associate Asia director, Patricia Gossman, said prosecuting the lawyers for terrorism sends a “chilling message to everyone who speaks up for fundamental rights.” The group argues that Pakistan’s broadly worded anti-terrorism laws should not be applied to allegations of obstruction or public disorder. Pakistan’s law minister, Azam Nazeer Tarar, has repeatedly said the country’s judiciary is independent, Reuters noted.

Arrested again within hours

This is not the first time the pair have been jailed this year. They were arrested on 23 January in a separate case, and the next day a sessions court sentenced each of them to 17 years under the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act over social media posts that prosecutors described as anti-state. Amnesty International called those charges politically motivated.

On 17 September, Pakistan’s Supreme Court suspended those sentences and ordered their release on bail. Police re-arrested them within hours in the barrier case. On 30 September, UN human rights experts called for their immediate release, saying the successive prosecutions appeared intended to punish them for their views and advocacy.

Ms Mazari-Hazir is internationally known for speaking out about enforced disappearances. Together, the couple have represented journalists, activists, people accused of blasphemy, victims of sexual violence and prisoners facing the death penalty, according to HRW.

What happens next

The couple’s counsel, Zainab Janjua, told Arab News they will challenge the decision, and the family has said it will petition the Supreme Court. Separate legal challenges are already in motion: before the verdict, the couple asked the Supreme Court to review the Islamabad High Court’s refusal to halt the trial, and the High Court is still hearing their appeal against the inclusion of terrorism charges. Any ruling in those cases could shape whether the 10-year sentences stand. Rights groups, including HRW and UN experts, are expected to keep up pressure for their release.

Sources

Featured image: Supreme Court of Pakistan, Islamabad by Usman Ghani by Usman.pg, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.