Home Business Property Ireland’s biggest landlord I-Res under fire over ‘tenant swap’ ban as charity warns renters could be forced from homes

Ireland’s biggest landlord I-Res under fire over ‘tenant swap’ ban as charity warns renters could be forced from homes

Brick apartment building

Ireland’s largest private landlord is under fire over a policy that critics warn could quietly push renters out of their homes. I-Res, which owns more than 3,500 homes across the country, has confirmed that it generally does not allow new tenants to be added to existing leases, a practice widely known as “tenant swapping”.

The company set out its position in a letter to the Oireachtas housing committee, The Irish Times reported on Friday 30 October. It said each request is looked at individually, but that its general rule has been in place since May 2025, before the Government announced its latest overhaul of rental law.

What is tenant swapping and why does it matter?

In a shared home, it is common for one housemate to move out and for someone new to take their place on the lease. For many renters, especially couples who split up or friends sharing a flat, that is the only way to keep a home when one person’s income disappears.

Housing charity Threshold says the stakes have risen because of the new rental regime. Under rules that took effect for tenancies created from 1 March 2026, a landlord can reset the rent to the market rate when a new tenancy begins if the previous tenant left by choice, according to the Residential Tenancies Board (RTB). Tenancies that began before that date cannot be reset to market rent in that way.

Gareth Redmond, research and policy officer at Threshold, told The Irish Times that a strict line on swapping, combined with the ability to reset rent once a home is vacated, could effectively force people from their homes. Remaining tenants who cannot cover the full rent on their own may have little real choice but to leave, he argued, and he suggested the law may need to change.

Politicians call it ‘constructive eviction’

Social Democrats housing spokesperson Rory Hearne went further. He said tenants had been raising the issue with him, described refusals to allow swaps as a form of constructive eviction, and called on Housing Minister James Browne to step in. He also said I-Res had declined to appear before the housing committee and urged the company to stop the practice.

READ MORE

I-Res rejects the idea that it is acting unfairly. In its letter, the company said its approach is a general policy rather than a one-size-fits-all rule, and that its aim is to make sure everyone living in its homes has a clear, legally recognised status. It said it had run into practical and legal problems in the past, including:

  • cases where relationship breakdowns led to barring orders between people sharing a tenancy;
  • undeclared occupants being charged higher rents by named tenants;
  • named tenants imposing unfair conditions on people subletting from them;
  • new people joining older leases who would not be covered by last year’s rental reforms.

The company said tenancies can change significantly when the people in them change, that disputes can be taken to the RTB, and it encouraged any tenant with concerns to contact it directly.

A landlord in the middle of a takeover

The row comes at a sensitive moment for I-Res. In September the company revealed it had received a possible all-cash takeover proposal from a unit of the investment firm Barings, valuing its shares at about €727 million. Its board has said it would be minded to recommend a firm offer if one is made, and under Irish takeover rules Barings has until 9 November to declare whether it will bid, The Irish Times and TheJournal.ie have reported.

At the time of that approach, I-Res said it had 3,611 homes, with occupancy above 99% and an average monthly rent of €1,884, according to TheJournal.ie.

What you can do if you rent from a large landlord

If you share a rented home and someone is planning to leave, check your lease and talk to your landlord in writing before anyone moves out. Keep copies of every exchange. The RTB’s published guidance explains which rules apply depending on when your tenancy started, and Threshold offers free advice to renters. If you believe you are being treated unfairly, a dispute can be lodged with the RTB.

This article is general information, not legal or financial advice.

What happens next

Pressure is now on the Minister for Housing to say whether he will intervene, and on the Oireachtas housing committee to decide how hard to pursue I-Res after it declined to appear. Threshold’s call for a legislative fix could feature in future debates on the rental reforms. Meanwhile, all eyes are on the 9 November takeover deadline, which will decide whether Ireland’s biggest private landlord gets a new owner.

Sources

Featured image: photo by Compagnons on Unsplash.