The League Cup has a long tradition of humbling big clubs, but few nights compare with what happened on the Lancashire coast on Tuesday. Fleetwood Town, sitting in the bottom half of League Two, knocked out reigning Premier League champions Arsenal on penalties after a 1-1 draw at Highbury Stadium, sending the Cod Army into the quarter-finals for the first time in the club’s history.
According to ESPN, it is the first time the reigning English champions have been beaten by a fourth-tier team in the competition. For a club that was playing non-League football as recently as 2012, it was also Fleetwood’s first ever victory over a top-flight side.
How the upset unfolded
Mikel Arteta rotated heavily, with Declan Rice, Gabriel and David Raya all absent from the matchday squad, ESPN reported. Illan Meslier made his Arsenal debut in goal, Northern Ireland teenager Cedach O’Neill was handed his first start, and Viktor Gyökeres and Kai Havertz led the attack.
The evening had an odd start when a drone over the ground halted play for around seven minutes early in the first half, Sky Sports reported. Fleetwood then went ahead in the 21st minute through Aaron Loupalo-Bi, a forward on loan from Fulham. Arsenal levelled five minutes after the restart when Gyökeres scored his first goal of the season, and Martin Ødegaard was introduced at half-time to help push for a winner. Havertz in particular was left to rue a string of missed chances.
Instead, the visitors’ night soured further near the end. Sixteen-year-old Max Dowman was shown a straight red card for violent conduct after kicking out at Fleetwood’s Harrison Neal following a heavy challenge.
In the shootout Fleetwood were flawless. Goalkeeper Jay Lynch saved from Bruno Guimarães, and teenage defender Conor Haughey converted the decisive kick to seal a 5-3 win and spark a pitch invasion. Fleetwood manager Matt Lawlor admitted afterwards that his side had not rehearsed penalties at all, according to Sky Sports.
Arteta’s reaction and a costly red card
Arteta described it as “a really sad day for us”, according to ESPN. He said he could not fault his players’ attitude, but stressed that a team with so much possession had to convert its chances and avoid a lottery from the spot.
READ MORE
- Etihad hoodoo SMASHED as Brighton stun Man City, then Havertz fires Arsenal top with first Anfield win in 14 years
- Liverpool boost for Arsenal clash as Iraola says Szoboszlai and Munoz ‘have a chance’ – but injury list grows
- Champions League week ahead: Carrick’s Roma D-Day, Villa’s Barcelona test and Liverpool’s perfect record on the line – every kick-off in Irish time
The fallout continued into the week. Arsenal appealed Dowman’s dismissal, but an independent commission for the Football Association rejected the club’s claim of wrongful dismissal, Sky Sports reported on Thursday. The teenager will serve a three-match domestic ban, ruling him out of Sunday’s Premier League trip to Liverpool as well as games against Hull and Newcastle.
Speaking on Friday, Arteta said the club was very disappointed by the outcome. He made clear that, while Arsenal take great care of Dowman, he will be held to the same standards as any senior player, according to ESPN.
A familiar pattern of giant-killing
The result revives uncomfortable memories for Arsenal, who also went out of this competition on penalties to a fourth-tier side when Bradford City beat them in the 2012-13 quarter-finals. It also extends a run of shootout pain that includes their defeat to Paris Saint-Germain in the 2025 Champions League final, ESPN noted.
Fleetwood’s players said they had taken inspiration from Grimsby Town, the League Two side that knocked Manchester United out of last season’s competition on penalties. Lawlor’s side are 18th in League Two and only two points above the relegation places, so the cup run is a welcome lift for a squad battling at the wrong end of the table.
It was not the only notable result of the round. Liverpool edged out Chelsea 6-5 on penalties, Manchester City beat Brighton in a shootout, and Bradford City, Bournemouth, Crystal Palace, Sunderland and Everton also progressed, according to Sports Illustrated’s round-up.
What happens next
Fleetwood’s reward is a home quarter-final against Everton, with the last-eight ties scheduled for the week of 14 December. The other quarter-finals pair Manchester City with Bradford City, Crystal Palace with Sunderland, and Liverpool with Bournemouth.
For Arsenal, attention turns straight back to the league and a demanding trip to Anfield on Sunday without Dowman. Lawlor, meanwhile, told his players to enjoy the night, with a League Two fixture already looming on Saturday.
Sources
- ESPN: Arsenal stunned in Carabao Cup loss to fourth-tier Fleetwood Town (27 October 2026)
- Sky Sports: Fleetwood 1-1 Arsenal (5-3 pens) (28 October 2026)
- Sports Illustrated: 2026-27 Carabao Cup quarter-final draw (28 October 2026)
- Sky Sports: Max Dowman red card appeal rejected (29 October 2026)
- ESPN: Mikel Arteta warning to Max Dowman after red card (30 October 2026)
Featured image: Highbury stadium by Harvestman, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

