Home Ireland Crime & Law Blood on the stairs: Waterford man with 63 previous convictions jailed for three years over People’s Park assault, as judge throws out his ‘apology’

Blood on the stairs: Waterford man with 63 previous convictions jailed for three years over People’s Park assault, as judge throws out his ‘apology’

Waterford city centre

A Waterford man who attacked another man near the entrance to the city’s People’s Park, leaving him with a deep wound and covered in blood, has been jailed for three years.

Conor Manning, aged 31, of no fixed abode, was sentenced by Judge O’Kelly, according to a report in the Irish Examiner’s Waterford News & Star section published on Wednesday evening, 28 October. The judge was unimpressed by a letter of apology handed in on Manning’s behalf, describing it as not acceptable to the court.

Blood on the floor and stairs

The court heard that on 4 May 2024 gardaí received reports of men fighting on William Street, close to the entrance to People’s Park, one of the city’s best-known green spaces.

When officers arrived, they found the injured man with a deep cut and blood all over his body. The person who attacked him had already left. The victim told gardaí he believed his attacker had gone into an apartment on William Street.

Inside that apartment, gardaí found blood on the floor and on the stairs, and identified Manning. An investigating garda told the court Manning was abusive towards officers and tried to force his way past them, which led to a scuffle. He was arrested and taken to Waterford Garda Station. The victim needed hospital treatment.

A long record, and on bail at the time

The court was told that Manning has 63 previous convictions, five of them for assault. He was on bail when the attack happened. He is currently serving a sentence of seven and a half years for an unrelated offence.

The apology that fell flat

Manning’s solicitor handed in a letter of apology. However, the court heard it was undated and was addressed only, in vague terms, to “the victim”.

READ MORE

Judge O’Kelly rejected it, telling the court it was “not acceptable to this court”, before imposing a prison term of three years.

Judges in Ireland routinely weigh expressions of remorse, guilty pleas and personal circumstances when deciding on sentence. A letter of apology is often presented as evidence that an offender accepts responsibility, but courts have repeatedly signalled that a generic or last-minute note carries little weight.

Why offending on bail matters

The fact that Manning was on bail at the time of the attack is significant. Under Irish law, where a person commits an offence while on bail, the court is generally required to treat that as an aggravating factor when deciding on sentence, and any sentence for the new offence is normally to be served consecutively to a sentence for the earlier offence. The Irish Examiner report did not say how the judge applied those rules in this case.

Repeat offending has become a recurring theme in debate about public safety in Irish towns and cities, with gardaí and local representatives in Waterford, as elsewhere, pointing to a small number of prolific offenders who account for a large share of street violence and public order incidents.

What happens next

Manning will serve the three-year term while already in custody on his existing sentence. The report did not state whether the new sentence is to run consecutively with, or concurrently to, the seven-and-a-half-year term he is serving, which will determine how much extra time he spends behind bars.

There is no indication in the report of any appeal. Under Irish law, a convicted person can lodge an appeal against severity of sentence with the Court of Appeal, normally within 28 days, and the Director of Public Prosecutions can seek a review of a sentence considered unduly lenient.

Anyone affected by violent crime can contact Crime Victims Helpline on 116 006.

Sources

Featured image: City of Waterford – geograph.org.uk – 33684.jpg by Tom Courtney, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.