Enzo Maresca has insisted that nobody at Manchester City is undroppable, but the head coach has made it clear that Gianluigi Donnarumma will be straight back between the posts for Saturday’s Premier League meeting with Brighton.
The Italian goalkeeper came under fire after last weekend’s 2-1 defeat at Aston Villa, with reports pointing to his part in both of the goals conceded. Then, in midweek, his deputy Geronimo Rulli made two saves in a penalty shoot-out as City came from behind twice to draw 2-2 with Brighton in the League Cup before going through, according to AFP.
That set up an obvious question at Maresca’s Friday press conference: does Rulli deserve a run in the side?
‘Gigio plus 10’
Maresca’s answer was a careful balancing act. He drew a distinction between saying his first-choice side is currently built around Donnarumma and saying the keeper is untouchable. “In this moment it is Gigio plus 10,” he said, as reported by AFP, before stressing that no player in his squad is guaranteed a place.
The City boss also played down the Villa errors, saying that every player makes mistakes at some stage of a season, and pointed to an important late save Donnarumma made in the win away to Manchester United as proof of his quality, according to 101 Great Goals.
It is a show of faith in a goalkeeper who was signed to be City’s long-term number one. But by publicly leaving the door open, Maresca has also handed Rulli a clear incentive to keep pushing.
Maresca also moved to clarify earlier remarks about his reserve keeper, explaining that being first choice right now is not the same as having a guaranteed place for the rest of the season. In other words, Donnarumma keeps the gloves on merit, not by right, and the Argentinian’s shoot-out display has been noted.
READ MORE
- Etihad hoodoo SMASHED as Brighton stun Man City, then Havertz fires Arsenal top with first Anfield win in 14 years
- Emery’s blunt warning to Aston Villa stars after Bournemouth cup thrashing: Premier League comes first
- Champions League week ahead: Carrick’s Roma D-Day, Villa’s Barcelona test and Liverpool’s perfect record on the line – every kick-off in Irish time
For a club used to stability in goal, it is an unusual debate. City have rarely had to answer questions about their number one, and how Donnarumma responds under the Etihad spotlight could shape the conversation for weeks to come.
Only one absentee
On the injury front, City are in good shape. Antoine Semenyo is the only player ruled out, with the winger recovering from a knee problem. Maresca said it was too early to talk about his return, according to Fantasy Football Scout.
Matheus Nunes is back after a short absence, while Iliman Ndiaye is fit after being forced off with cramp last weekend. Asked whether Phil Foden and Rayan Cherki can play together, Maresca said they can, depending on the game.
That gives the head coach a near-full squad to choose from, and a selection puzzle in midfield and attack as City try to bounce back from the defeat at Villa Park.
Brighton out for revenge
The fixture has extra spice after Wednesday’s cup drama. City go into the weekend top of the table, level on points with Arsenal and ahead on goal difference, while Brighton are third. Brighton head coach Fabian Hurzeler has said his side want revenge for the shoot-out defeat, AFP reported.
Off the pitch, the cloud over the club has not gone away. AFP noted that City are appealing against last month’s guilty verdict on more than 100 charges of breaching Premier League financial rules, a process that continues in the background of their title push.
What happens next
City host Brighton at the Etihad on Saturday 31 October. With Arsenal travelling to Liverpool on Sunday, Maresca’s side have the chance to put pressure on their rivals by winning first.
All eyes will be on Donnarumma. A clean, confident display would ease the debate quickly; another costly mistake would make Rulli’s case very hard to ignore going into the November international break.
Sources
- Yahoo Sports UK (AFP): Maresca adamant Donnarumma can be dropped but first name selected (30 October 2026)
- Fantasy Football Scout: Semenyo, Ndiaye, Nunes: Man City injury latest for FPL Gameweek 9 (30 October 2026)
- 101 Great Goals: Maresca insists no Man City player is undroppable after Donnarumma’s Villa horror show (30 October 2026)
- CBS Sports: Villa look to build Premier League momentum against Fulham (30 October 2026)
Featured image: Gianluigi Donnarumma in Milanello 2020 by Calciopedia, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

